Thursday, March 6

A Fun Musical Interlude

Ok, here's a little game to lighten things up (like a match in the pitch-black tar of Plato's cave of reality, doomed to die, illuminating nothing but flickering shadows of perfect things we will never see because they don't exist unless we look at them directly, like a photon or an electron or a neturino in chocolate, vanilla, or pistachio flavors).

This is for fun, there are no right answers (although I'll probably think you're a tit if you say something stupid).

Three perfect (or nearly perfect) albums in a row. Some great artists have never accomplished this, like John Lennon, who almost did it with Plastic Ono Band, Imagine, and Mind Games, but he had to stick A Little Time In NYC in there and break the chain. But some musical artists get on a roll and can do no wrong for a period of time. More than a few have put out 3 or more masterworks consecutively. Live albums, greatest hits, and movie soundtracks don't count as interrupting the studio flow.

I'll give a few easy examples, (to take those away, muahaha) and then whoever wants to can weigh in with their own! Be as obvious or obscure as you want: It's what YOU think are great albums that matters, not Rolling Stone or the NME or the music intelligentsia. But they do have to be consecutive releases. Go beyond three if you feel like you need to; I've done this several times in my own list. Or correct me if you think I'm full of it some of my choices! It's all in good fun. At least until someone loses an eye.

Bob Dylan: Bringing It All Back Home, Highway 61 Revisited, Blonde On Blonde
Leonard Cohen: The Songs of Leonard Cohen, Songs from a Room, Songs of Love and Hate
Bowie (set 1): Hunky Dory, Ziggy Stardust, Aladdin Sane
Bowie (set 2): Station to Station, Low, Heroes, Lodger, Scary Monsters
The Beach Boys: Today, Summer Days (and Summer Nights!), Pet Sounds
The Clash: London Calling, Sandinista!, Combat Rock
Elvis Costello: My Aim Is True, This Year's Model, Armed Forces
The Smiths: The Smiths, Meat Is Murder, The Queen Is Dead, Louder Than Bombs, Strangeways Here We Come
The Beatles: Revolver, Rubber Soul, Sgt. Pepper's, Magical Mystery Tour, The Beatles, Abbey Road, Let It Be
The Who: Tommy, Who's Next, Quadrophenia
Dan Fogelberg: Home Free, Souvenirs, Captured Angel, Nether Lands, Phoenix, The Innocent Age
Radiohead: The Bends, OK Computer, Kid A
The Cure: Seventeen Seconds, Faith, Pornography
The Boss: Born to Run, Darkness on the Edge of Town, The River, Nebraska
Bob Marley: Natty Dread, Rastaman Vibration, Exodus, Kaya
The Beastie Boys: Licensed to Ill, Paul's Boutique, Check your head, Ill Communication
Depeche Mode: Some Great Reward, Black Celebration, Music For The Masses, Violator
Steely Dan: Katy Lied, Royal Scam, Aja
REM: Murmer, Reckoning, Fables of the Reconstruction, Life's Rich Pageant, Document, Green
The Police: Outlandos D'Amour, Regatta De Blanc, Zenyatta Mondatta, Ghost In The Machine, Synchronicity
Pink Floyd: Meddle, Dark Side Of The Moon, Wish You Were Here, Animals, The Wall, The Final Cut
Nick Drake: Five Leaves Left, Bryter Layter, Pink Moon
They Might Be Giants: They Might Be Giants, Lincoln, Flood


19 comments:

Unknown said...

Grrr, I was reading and ´oooh Nick Drake´. Then I scrolled down. I´ll have another think.

Metamatician said...

Sorry I snaked your first choice. You can always 'second' a choice I've made, to bolster my ego and make yourself look cool in the process ;)

Sara said...

I'm not going to even try. This is too hard. Apart from Your first three Pink Floyd choices and possibly three of Bowie's I doubt I've ever considered three albums in a row to be perfect. There's always on or two tracks that blow it. Take Abbey Road for example; not quite perfect I'm afraid, which idiot decided to include Maxwell's Silver Hammer?

I may on second thoughts, grudgingly agree to include Coldplay: Parachutes, A Rush of Blood to The Head and X&Y, because they are consistent. This is very rare.

Sara said...

By the way Raelha, what's happened to your blog? Apparently I need permission to access it. Sob.

Thesaurus Rex said...

Led Zep 2,3, 4symbols. (Eezee Peezee Lemon Skweezee)
Hey Meta and Maggy, ever heard of that band Codplay. They did 2 albums so far, 'Lost Consonants' and 'All Back to My Plaice'
Rumour has it the next one's in the can, entitled 'Dr. Worm'
Think they'll get sued?

Metamatician said...

Rex, I was waiting for those Zep albums to be named!

Mags, I love you dearly but anyone who suggests Coldplay for a list like this and furthermore disses the Beatles finest album in the process is automagically disqualified. You're the weakest link, see ya later.

Unknown said...

Mags, sorry! It´s not just you, it´s everyone who isn´t invited. I hope to be back soon. I have a few ´real life´ problems to deal with at the moment and it was just easier to take the blog offline while they´re running their course and I get my head straight.

Sara said...

Ok Raelha, hope all improves very soon.

Rex. Doh! How could I miss the obvious. See, told you I was very tired and needing sleep.

Meta. Anyone who thinks Maxwell's Silver Hammer is a good song should be automatically disqualified. Pleeeeeeeeeze! Just because they're the Beatles does not make everything they wrote, brilliant. Far from it. Much of their material is pure tripe. Fortunately there is some that's brilliant, but discrimination is necessary. They were not musical gods; just a bunch of scousers who took a lot of drugs and had some interesting ideas that were definitely ahead of their time. John Lennon was a remarkable man on a lot of levels, the rest of them..... well, I'm not so sure.

Metamatician said...

Bullshit, they were too musical gods, and I said "perfect or nearly perfect" and no one can tell me Abbey Road isn't a nearly perfect album. One track doesn't ruin one of the greatest albums ever. Otherwise you're right, there are VERY few albums without a single duff track.

Coldplay are consistent, true; consistently mediocre. This is more of the same banal, 30-something mellow rock which is blown up into something more than it is, like Oasis or Dido. I like Oasis, but they've been very inconsistent since their one brilliant album. Blur won that battle a long time ago (even though Oasis IMO had a couple songs better than anything Blur did). I like Dido a lot too, but I don't consider her great in any sense. Just nice-sounding adult rock you can clean your house too or put on in the car, like Norah Jones.

I'll put Abbey road up against all 3 Coldplay albums at once and still get some change back. The Fab Four + George Martin had more musical talent and originality in their little fingers than Chris Martin has in his whole Gwyneth-addled brain.

Of course, that's only my opinion. :)

Anonymous said...

Maybe it's just NYC getting the best of me, but I submit as evidence this four-in-a-row freakshow:

The Velvet Underground and Nico
White Light/White Heat
The Velvet Underground
Loaded

Metamatician said...

Excellent choices!

JOVIAN said...

First, about Coldplay: first album was very good, the second was mediocre, the third sucked &*!.

Secondly, I disagree with a couple of your choices. I personally don't think 'Blonde on Blonde' is a very good album (see 'Blood on the Tracks'). Also, 'Revolver' and 'Rubber Soul' are flawed individually but would have made a great single album. There are a couple other possible gripes but I will toss those aside in favor of...who the hell is 'The Boss'?

All in all, very good choices, especially about 'The Smiths', Nick Drake, 'The Clash', Bowie,...uh, most of the others.

I'll see if I can't think of some more obscure offerings.

H

JOVIAN said...

ah yeah, how about ALL of The Chameleons (proper) albums?

JOVIAN said...

ok, here's another one: Fleetwood Mac's Eponymous, 'Rumors', and 'Tusk'.

JOVIAN said...

oh yeah, and The Swans' 'Children of God', 'White Light from the Mouth of Infinity', and 'Love of Life'. Of course, this is far from mainstream, but YOU KNOW.

Hans said...

I have to agree with Dan Fogelberg (for me) and Norah Jones put out 3 great albums in a row. I'll be back with more after the break.

Metamatician said...

I definitely agree with both The Chameleons and Swans. "The Boss" is Bruce Springstein, youngster :)

I need to hear more of Norah's earlier stuff; I actually tuned her out for a long time because she was popular. Pretty much the same with Coldplay and lots of other bands. I figured if they were popular they must suck.

What I think doesn't matter at all though - hearing what other peoples' lists are is the fun part.

Rex, you codpiece, why haven't you ever put out an album yourself? It could be little ditties on guitar interrupted by long spoken-word performances. You'd sell dozens.

Thesaurus Rex said...

I did put out an album, albeit alongside 3 other guys in a band. Needless to say, with our stoner logic, stoner business ecumen, arrogant assumption that if people don't like it, it's their problem, it bombed. Didn't even sell dozens.
I like the idea of ditties and long monologues. I feel others have done it before and probably better. Now, on with the decorating.

Metamatician said...

Nonsense, you tosser. It's never too late to be an over the hill rock guru.

Congrats on the original album though!

Archived Posts

Search The Meta-Plane