Thursday, September 25

Bands.

Is there a better debut album than Placebo's self-titled one? Well, there are, but not very many. I like the group a lot but their work, taken as a whole, puts them on the second-tier category for me. But if all their albums were like their first, they'd be tier-one all the way. The same goes for Suede, now that I think about it. Brilliant debut, followed by a string of good but somehow flawed albums. Compare both of these groups to Radiohead, whose debut album was just above-average except for the standout hit "Creep," and then the band topped it with a much more polished second effort, and the rest is history. Like the Beatles, from fairly conventional beginnings, they went on to completely define a new sound. When someone asks you what genre Radiohead (or The Beatles) are, you just kinda scratch your head and say... "Radiohead." Bowie has always done his own thing as well. Then there are groups whose sound always stays the same; they play it safe and stay with what works. Exhibit A: The Cranberries. Anyways, just some observations about what bands do after their debut album. This could be a topic that went on and on, but then I would lose my tiny readership entirely.

But for fun, can you think a good examples of bands that you like that a) Had a great debut album which they never matched again, b) Had inauspicious beginnings but grew to be a great band, and c) A band which always put out good material but never really pushed their creative frontiers? Be fun to see what people come up with.

5 comments:

Unknown said...

Hmm, you have me thinking. More later...

Hans said...

Dating myself, but Crosby Stills and Nash, which started with Buffalo Springfield, came to mind. Here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30W3iRL48gQ

Hans said...

Also, Buffalo Springfield was the first concert I attended, and at Rolling Hills High School of all places! They branched off to become Crosby, Stills, and Nash, (then Young too), then some went off to start Poco - a band that was great but didn't last.

Metamatician said...

Good one. So is that your example of a band that started good and just got better, or that maintained their quality throughout? I'd have to say the latter... they were and always have been, in all their forms (Poco, Neil Young and Crazy Horse, CSN, etc). Even Crosby and Nash just a couple years ago at that David Gilmour concert still sounded great. I was amazed actually how good the three of them sounded together, it was great!

Hans said...

They started out great and stayed great even through a lot of changes - they simply have great harmonies and great songs. I can't say that any one person stood out as incredible, but put the right people together and it's magic. The Everly Brothers, The Beach Boys, The Eagles, Fleetwood Mac, Beatles, Chicago...getting off the subject a bit.

Archived Posts

Search The Meta-Plane