Two modes of thought.
Philosophy typically works using deductive reasoning.
Science typically works using inductive reasoning.
Religion typically doesn't work at all, using any reasoning.
Some definitions...
Deduction:
One makes up one's mind on something, then uses logic and whatever appropriate logical loopholes can be imagined and convincingly argued, to show that this opinion is the way "it really is." In the end charisma and/or intimidation often come into play.
Induction:
Same as deduction, except one additionally gathers facts that support one's hunch, ignores those that don't, then arranges and presents the "good" facts so as to make it seem that Nature herself agrees on the point. This is more convincing than deduction, so science generally beats philosophy the way paper somehow beats rock.
Saturday, December 20
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I am...
Archived Posts
-
▼
2008
(226)
-
▼
December
(25)
- A few of my favourite things.My usual list compuls...
- JeaneJeane The low-life has lost its appealAnd I'm...
- SaffronSpirit rise to greet the suntakes my hand a...
- This company's products look way too awesome.Check...
- Hymn For The Fallen.My attends to you as a mother ...
- Hmm. Don't think I like that one.
- Iatrogenesis.I woke up todayout of a fog.How long ...
- The day it rained forever.River silences.A tree ga...
- I Can See Now.Ever loved a woman who made you feel...
- Take the Magic: The Gathering 'What Color Are You?...
- Two modes of thought.Philosophy typically works us...
- I Am A: Lawful Good Human Monk/Ranger (3rd/2nd Lev...
- Boy who came in from the coldWet and shivering ste...
- nowI live in the now. From moment to moment there ...
- surrealism(found art and manipulation)
- VI.light bringer,sees the true darknesswhatcan nev...
- The quiz is coming.I've had some mental problems t...
- I like vegetables a lot. In fact, some of my best ...
- Life is absurdLook what it's done to meBorn a happ...
- PUB QUIZ #1(NEWFANGLED PHENOTYPE)Hello and thank y...
- THE UNITED KINGDOM
- Hey, it's malfucntioning! It's giving that old gee...
- Ok, so here's the deal on the quiz...There will be...
- Pub quiz anyone?I've got loads of questions writte...
- In Power We Entrust The Love Advocated.Sail on sil...
-
▼
December
(25)
5 comments:
Hmm. As a historian I could only ever argue a point of view if I could prove it with examples, the more the better. Anything that discounted my arguments couldn't be ignored and had to be incorporated into my explaining of that history. How does that fit in?
Eh...I was just trying to be sarcastic about both reasoning methods. I guess I didn't do a very good job.
Reasoning from examples would be inductive reasoning, and of course you should use ALL available facts and not cherry pick only those that support your theory.
You shouldn't even really have a theory, you'd start from hypotheses that occurred to you as you looked over data (in the case of history, say you read an old eyewitness account of some event, and it seems different from what modern historians have concurred happened - not that they ever concur. But maybe some new idea suggests itself to you - Jack the Ripper was a woman!! ...or something).
Then you test your hypothesis to see if it fits all the facts, and the more it does, the stronger your case becomes. Anyways, you know how it all works, although history is a more subjective thing than something like physics.
And there's still a place for deductive reasoning too, such as the ancient Greeks liked to use - reasoning from first principles. That's the way mathematics works and opposed to science.
Well we could talk about logical argumentation forever, but I don't feel like it right now. Heh.
Maybe I'll do a serious piece on it sometime. Here I was just trying to be witty or sardonic or one of those other words.
*'as opposed to science', I meant to say.
It's late here, I half missed the sarcasm. I was going to and some hopefully witty comment about religion have no need for any thought whatsover but my sleepiness messed that up too.
You need to get to bed!
Post a Comment